A man is holding a smart phone in his hand. Photo. Photo: Mostphotos.
K2

User control important for personalised travel information in public transport

Personalised travel information is widely regarded as the next major innovation in public transport. At the same time, there is currently no structured method for comparing different solutions. In her licentiate thesis, Michelle van Ardenne, a doctoral student at KTH and K2, has examined different forms of personalisation and how travellers relate to them.

Personalised travel information aims to increase the personal relevance of information for individual travellers. This can be achieved by filtering, ranking or adapting information based on personal or contextual factors.

The field is highly topical and is widely seen as the next major innovation in travel information. One important reason is that personalisation is believed to improve travellers’ experience of public transport by reducing the cognitive burden associated with journey planning.

At the same time, personalisation can be designed in many different ways. Despite the interest in the issue, there is currently no structured evaluation method that makes it possible to compare different applications for personalised travel information. As a result, it is difficult to determine the added value that different personalisation strategies provide in travellers’ everyday lives. One contributing factor is that these solutions are often developed for specific public transport systems.

“The purpose of my study is to create a structure for our understanding of personalisation while also gaining insights into its added value in public transport more broadly, so that this added value can be compared across different public transport systems,” says Michelle van Ardenne.

She also hoped to gain an understanding of how travellers respond to the various forms of personalisation that exist.

Travellers want to be actively involved in personalisation

In her licentiate thesis, she reviewed 40 articles on the introduction of personalised travel information and compared personalisation features in two commercial journey-planning apps: Region Stockholm’s SL app and the Dutch national railway operator NS travel app, both of which provide multimodal travel information. The results show that five different levels of personalisation can be distinguished. These levels differ in the degree of automation and involve varying levels of traveller participation.

The findings also show that travellers in Stockholm prefer to be actively involved in the personalisation process themselves. A high degree of automated personalisation gave rise to concerns about personal privacy. Examples of concerns included personal data being stored insecurely or being sold to third parties without consent.

“It was surprising that travellers do not always appreciate more data-driven mobile applications, which does not align with the general trend towards digitalisation and personalisation in other sectors,” says Michelle van Ardenne, who nevertheless believes that there is potential for more automated levels of personalisation if privacy concerns can be addressed.

One recommendation is that app developers should allow a certain degree of user control, for example by enabling travellers to correct the system and delete data that they do not want to be included in the personalisation process.

The hope is that the study will help public transport authorities advance their work on personalised travel information more quickly.

Link to the licentiate thesis in the DiVA portal:
The potential of personalized travel information in public transportation